Q. What else might NASA have done?
A. Some people wanted to see NASA fund a new competition, a Commercial Crew 2.0 for the 2030s. This would have brought on a competitor, probably Blue Origin but maybe also someone like Sierra Nevada or The Exploration Company, to keep price pressure on Boeing for crew transportation services. However, a new competition would ultimately have cost NASA billions of dollars, and Isaacman seems reluctant to make such an investment given all of NASA’s other priorities. Isaacman believes Boeing can meet NASA’s needs, which are something like two seats every six to nine months, to orbit. The real unknown is whether a market beyond NASA—institutional customers from Europe, the Middle East, and beyond, in addition to privately funded astronauts—could exist at Starliner’s prices.
:
Q. What about Blue Origin?
A. The space company founded by Jeff Bezos is developing a “Space Vehicle” for astronauts to launch on the New Glenn rocket. After some of my recent reporting, sources reached out to let me know that design work is “well advanced” along with demonstration work such as cabin pressure-vessel manufacturing, extensive parachute testing, in-house thermal protection system testing, life support systems, and more. I’ve heard “no earlier than” dates of 2031 for a crew launch. But that’s probably optimistic, and if NASA and private space station operators need to book transport in the early 2030s, Starliner is probably the only option.
:
Q. What other vehicles are out there?
A. NASA relied on Russian Soyuz vehicles in the 2010s after the Space Shuttle retired, and before Crew Dragon came online. With Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, Soyuz is off the table for private space stations. India is also developing a crewed spacecraft, Gaganyaan. But it was originally supposed to carry humans in late 2021, and the schedule has since slipped to at least 2027. And for a time Gaganyaan is likely to be used solely for Indian missions. Counting on this vehicle for private space stations seems like a stretch. NASA does have its Orion spacecraft, but the per-seat cost for its missions is likely astronomical ($500 million per seat?), and Orion is needed for lunar missions. The Exploration Company, based in Europe, has ambitious plans for a crewed spacecraft, but it likely won’t be ready until 2035. Sierra Nevada’s Dream Chaser just does not seem like it’s ever going to happen, sorry.